Guide for local businesses
Is newsletter advertising worth it for a local business?
By Tom Otto, founder of Hey Cities ·
When a newsletter ad pays off for a local business, when it doesn't, the questions to ask before you book, and how to work out if it was worth it.
Short answer: it can be very good value, for the right kind of business, in the right newsletter, with the right ad. Get any one of those wrong and it's money down the drain. This guide is about telling the difference before you pay.
We should say up front that we sell newsletter ads, so we have an interest here. We've tried to write the guide we'd want to read if we were on the other side of the counter.
What you're actually buying
A newsletter ad is a slot in an email that goes to people who signed up to get it. That's the big difference from a social media ad. On Facebook you're interrupting someone who came to see photos of their friends. In a newsletter, you're in something people chose to open, often because they want ideas or recommendations.
The flip side: an email gets read once, usually within a day or two, and then it's gone. A newsletter ad is a short burst of attention, not a permanent sign over your door.
When it works well
Newsletter ads tend to pay off when what you're selling is something people plan for:
- Events. Gigs, markets, workshops, quizzes, comedy nights, festivals. People read a what's-on email to decide what to do, so an event is exactly what they're looking for.
- Openings and launches. A new café, a new menu, a new class. There's a reason to try it now.
- Offers with a deadline. "Two for one on Thursdays in November" gives people a reason to act this week rather than "some time".
- Things people book. Classes, tables, treatments, tickets. Anything with a booking link turns interest into a sale in one click.
It also works best when the newsletter and your customers live in the same place. A local newsletter is only useful if its readers can actually come to you.
When it doesn't
Be honest with yourself about these:
- Emergency services. Nobody remembers a locksmith ad from last Wednesday when they're locked out on Saturday night. Search and your Google Business Profile do that job better.
- Very niche business-to-business services. A general local newsletter has a broad audience. If only one reader in a thousand could ever buy from you, the maths rarely works.
- When your website isn't ready. If the link goes to a slow page with no prices and no way to book, you'll pay for clicks that go nowhere. Fix the page first.
- One send as a final verdict. One ad in one week tells you something, but a bad week (rain, school holidays, a big match) can hide a good channel. Don't sign up for a year either. Two or three sends is a fair test.
Questions to ask before you book
Any newsletter worth advertising in will answer these without fuss.
- How many people get it, and how did they sign up? You want readers who chose to subscribe. A list that was bought or scraped will have poor engagement and could land your ad in spam folders.
- How many open it, and how many click? Ask for figures from recent sends, not a best-ever number. Be a little wary of very high open rates: some email apps now count an "open" automatically, so clicks are the more honest measure.
- Where are the readers? For a local business this matters more than the total. 2,000 readers in your town beats 20,000 spread across the country.
- How many other ads are in each issue? One sponsor among a handful of picks gets noticed. One of fifteen ads does not.
- Can I see a past issue? Look at it as a reader would. Is it something you'd open? Do the ads look like they belong?
- Will I get a report? You should find out how many people clicked your ad, at the very least.
How to work out if it was worth it
Before you book, decide what a customer is worth to you. Then, after the send, do the sum.
Say a feature costs £35 and your ad gets 40 clicks. That's under 90p a click. If 1 in 10 of those people books a £20 class, that's 4 bookings and £80 of sales from £35. If those people come back again, it's better still.
Now compare that with what you'd pay elsewhere for the same result. A click from a social or search ad aimed at a small local area can cost about the same or more, and those people didn't ask to hear from anyone.
The numbers will be different for you, but the method is the same: cost of the ad ÷ customers it brought in = cost per customer. If that's less than a customer is worth to you, it worked.
To get the second number, give the ad its own offer code or its own link, and ask new customers how they heard about you.
How to write an ad that gets clicked
A newsletter ad is small, so every word has to work.
- Say what it is in the headline. "Wreath-making workshop, Sat 6 Dec" beats "Get festive with us!".
- Give the facts readers need to decide: day, time, place, price. People skip anything that makes them go and find out.
- One thing, one link. Don't advertise your whole business. Advertise the one event or offer you most want people to act on, and link straight to where they can book or buy.
- A reason to act now. Limited spaces, an end date, an early-bird price.
- A real photo of the thing, the place, or the people. Stock photos get ignored.
Timing
Book the issue that lands just before people make their decision. For a weekend event, that's the midweek email of the same week. For a big event that sells out, add an earlier send three or four weeks out, then a reminder in the week itself.
Where Hey Cities fits
Hey Cities sends a short what's-on email every Wednesday morning in Reading, Bristol, Torbay, Plymouth, Exeter and Oxford, to 7,981 readers in all. A Top 5 Feature puts your event or business among that week's main picks for £35 per city, and afterwards you get a report with opens, clicks and a click map. It suits exactly the kind of things above: events, openings, offers and anything people book.
If you're not sure it fits your business, email us and ask. We'd rather tell you it won't work than take your money for an ad that doesn't.